Piano Player

Gamification: Pianists vs Computers

Reading Time: 1 minutes (ish)

A thought that spawned from the back of a great Quora discussion about the role games designers in the world of gamification.

You can program a computer to play the most stunning works of classical music. You can create vast orchestras who never miss a note, or simple and flawless solo piano performances.

So why is it that people still go to see live performances, or buy cds of real people playing the music?

Heart, soul, the x-factor if you will. That something that separates each of us and makes us all individual. You can teach anyone to do pretty much anything (within physical / mental limitations of course) and they can become good at it. However, some things come from deeper than just learning. They come from a deep understanding at an almost spiritual level.

So when you consider if games designers should be involved in gamification (a word built from the concept of using bits that make GAMES engaging), consider what you would rather listen to – a computer playing a note perfect, but soulless rendition of Mozart or the latest virtuoso pianist?

Now, go and read my interview with Richard Bartle to get a games designers view on it all 🙂 and Happy New Year. Real blogs resume this week!


Spread the love!

2 Responses

  1. I am saying we should include games designers – that’s my point 🙂

  2. Anthony Anthony says:

    what alternative to game designers being involved are you proposing?

Leave a Reply


Play the Game


Subscribe to our newsletter


Andrzej Marczewski
About Andrzej Marczewski twitter facebook    
Gamification thought leader and evangelist, I love to write about it, talk about it and bore people to death with it! If you really want to get to know me, check out the About page.

Trackback URL for this post: https://www.gamified.uk/2013/01/03/gamification-a-pianists-vs-computers/trackback/