Are Mario, YouTube & My Little Pony killing my Daughters Imagination?

I am a huge advocate of the benefit of games. They are amazing and I would quite happily argue with anyone shouting about games and violence, or games being bad for kids. I am also not against T.V. My youngest has amazing shape recognition, counting and even spelling and maths abilities – at three – thanks in large part to Team UmiZoomi!

However, I have started to notice a slightly concerning issue with my eldest daughter. She seems to have no imagination any more, or at least a very reduced functionality one!

She loves playing Super Mario on the DS, a great game by many people’s reckoning (I may be one of the few people who never really liked Mario). As video games go, it is pretty harmless, unless you are part of the Mushroom Protection League. However, one thing that is does not do, is really allow for imagination. It is not a creative game, nor is it meant to be.

She also loves watching programmes like My Little Pony. This is again a show that is devoid of any need for imagination or learning.

Finally, she loves watching YouTube. Her choice of video is the concern. She likes to watch two main types of video. Opening videos and videos of people playing with toys. The first is a strange strange concept for me. You watch people open up surprise eggs or blind bags. She even has her own channel where she does the same.

The other, people playing with toys is the most concerning though. She watches people playing with the toys that she already owns. When I asked her why, she said “Because the tell me how to play with my toys”.

My heart sank.

So I tried an experiment yesterday. I asked her to role four dice from our Rory’s Story Cubes and then draw a picture inspired by the dice or a little story. She couldn’t do it. I had to actually show her how to make a story up, and when I had done, she just copied it! My story was about a princess who had lost her crown and was helped by a friendly bee to find it. Hers was about a princes wearing a crown who had lost her bee!

That is not to say she can’t use her imagination, but it seems that she needs to really warm it up to get it going after playing games or watching videos that require none. It makes me consider imagination in a different way, like a muscle. It needs exercise to stay strong and if you are doing something that does not use it for any length of time, it needs to be warmed up first.

I need to get her into Minecraft!

Similar Posts:

Please wait...

2 thoughts on “Are Mario, YouTube & My Little Pony killing my Daughters Imagination?”

  1. That was so interesting to me, because i also think some aspects of modern life today ties down imagination of our new generation.
    I have a 4 yr old brother. He likes to play games on my iPad. These kind of games are his first entertaining priority. When game get’s harder, he doesn’t try to find a way through. instead, he put the game away or ask me to play for him.
    When i was a kid, i remember i built things with my toys, i played Role-Playing with my batman and spider man action figures, and i drew characters from my imagination on paper. for me, there was a world in my mind. but for my little brother, there is a world right in front of his eyes, in iPad, not in his mind.
    although good games give you few things and let you make the rest in your mind, just like old toys. I am a gamer so i’m not saying “games are bad” but they are not everything. Brain needs different ways to play with.


Leave a Comment